Advertisement

Advertisement

James Butler Jr.

Birth
Death
3 Jul 1881
Burial
Burial Details Unknown Add to Map
Memorial ID
View Source
Three members of the Taylor Underwood gang were incarcerated in the Dade County jail on charges of stealing horses.
On July 3, 1881, a band of disguised men overpowered Sheriff George W. Whitesides at night and removed William Underwood, James Butler, Jr. and Frank Craft from their cells. They were found by citizens later that morning hanging in a tree on the west side of the courthouse.

The identities of the masked men remain unknown. Sources indicate the horse theiving business in Dade County came to a halt.

Taylor Underwood was captured in Carthage, Missouri and sentenced to hang for the murder of Greenfield (MO) City Marshal John D. McElrath. He appealed and pled guilty to manslaughter and sentenced to life in the state penetentiary.
Three members of the Taylor Underwood gang were incarcerated in the Dade County jail on charges of stealing horses.
On July 3, 1881, a band of disguised men overpowered Sheriff George W. Whitesides at night and removed William Underwood, James Butler, Jr. and Frank Craft from their cells. They were found by citizens later that morning hanging in a tree on the west side of the courthouse.

The identities of the masked men remain unknown. Sources indicate the horse theiving business in Dade County came to a halt.

Taylor Underwood was captured in Carthage, Missouri and sentenced to hang for the murder of Greenfield (MO) City Marshal John D. McElrath. He appealed and pled guilty to manslaughter and sentenced to life in the state penetentiary.

Advertisement